Dumpy- that was your worst yet (td)

I`m sorry but that was shocking,Phemba was a massive runner for 400m out and a blind man could have called the winner

Ja, the guy just does not cut it unfortunately...()

Dumpy at his best again, calling Tomcat fourth when it ran second...()

Lol give the guy a break,he s been bashed a lot

And more to come if the guy doesn't get it right on Monday...

Maybe too much alcohol & commentating don't go well :)o

How about the last....called the wrong horse second.
You have to wait for the official result before you can be sure in PE.
It really is bad now!

How old is bumpy dumpy ?

I think he is close to 60 years

soodum Wrote:

---

> Lol give the guy a break,he s been bashed a lot
This guy has had more "breaks" than the local glass factory - in the old days (20 years ago) when PE racing was an also-ran we thought he was a local auctioneer that was calling races because there was no one else to do the job - he could not commentate then and cannot do so now - He should be judged on the errors he makes which are vast - if your GP made as many errors as he does on a daily basis he would have killed you by now. Phumelela have no regard for the customer and their fragile public image is again shown up with this "flagship" commentator

its truely shocking....no confidence to pick up the phone and listen to commentry...because what ever u hear ..its still in doubt...whats the sense....i thought i doubled up with american man and bhusende....only to realise that tomcat was second and not 4th...thats a huge discrepency....and when i watched the actuall race last night...it was'nt even close...tomcat a clear second on the outside....this has to be addressed...its an absolute joke.....and about going soft on the guy because of his age..is no excuse....the man is a drunk...and probably pissed by the last race...so these mistakes wont be condoned....its typical of the society we live in at the moment...drop the standards and just get on...we are told.....soon we will all be sick

Alistair Cohen AliCat_Cohen_90

As it gets. The angle is absolutely shocking and yes I guess after 30+ years he would have mastered it but let me make a point



Does he make as many mistakes at arlington? Where calling is far easier? U can post that if u like. PS he is in his 60s